You will need to use an alternate with a hardness of in excess of 7 on the Mohs scale; or else, you may just be throwing away electricity by running your tumbler. Polly Plastics sells a really rated rock tumbler grit package and ceramic tumbling filler media (Amazon connection) recommended https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=pfbid02CgAiVhZ4NSBg2uWJKv63dv2DiJ5boogSePEZHkVQmLVuEt7nUkYQj8Xa9tQHUAS6l&id=61562415773754&__cft__[0]=AZU7soqQRdi0-0z9paHiW1AUpnanPyDpEYLt-mj6wO2WbgCSws1klflwE0lBk0y87B6A9V3KBp6FYTS22w3irYlKtuO6xSAJW6nKk3y26fZNbGhJ441al1yPgRjjzL8Uvm1zM-JEMjujjIbyNY-TSNPyxOJfJFXxRkiMbjEwtV87ZerSmjT9OzixT_TScDwp9IydE1dFym7njNtshdjIOhya&__tn__=%2CO%2CP-R